Choose furnaces around fuel and installation needs

Gas, electric resistance, and oil furnaces differ in fuel supply, installation, and running costs. Check ductwork, venting, electrical capacity, and professional sizing; heat pumps are a separate heating alternative worth comparing.

AI generated guide.AI may make mistakes.Learn more
Know your options
Gas and oil furnaces need fuel and venting, while electric resistance furnaces avoid combustion but can cost more to run.
Gas furnaces
Burn natural gas or propane for strong heating output, but require equipment approved for your fuel, safe venting, and professional installation.
Best for
Heating homes with an existing gas supply and suitable venting
Price range
  • $2194 - $3285
Electric resistance furnaces
Use resistance elements without combustion venting, simplifying fuel requirements but potentially costing more to run where electricity is expensive.
Best for
Heating homes with modest heating needs where combustion venting is impractical
Price range
  • $1094 - $2161
Oil furnaces
Burn stored heating oil where piped gas is unavailable, but need tank space, fuel deliveries, venting, and regular servicing.
Best for
Replacing oil-fired heating where a serviceable tank is already installed
Price range
  • $1899 - $4753
Things to consider

How does heating fit into your home's layout, winter routine, and household budget?

Look at how you heat the home now. Keeping the existing fuel supply and ducts can avoid major installation work; changing them expands the project.

A furnace distributes heated air through ducts; fuel supply, electrical capacity, and exhaust routes can rule out otherwise suitable replacements.

    The installed cost matters more than the equipment price, especially when switching fuels or adding ductwork.

    Recall how you stayed warm during the coldest weather and any insulation upgrades since. Furnace capacity should match today's heat loss, not yesterday's equipment.

    A professional heating-load calculation estimates needed capacity using climate, insulation, windows, and air leakage, not square footage alone.

      Extra capacity isn't free insurance: oversizing can cause frequent starts and uneven temperatures, while undersizing can leave rooms cold during severe weather.

      Estimate how heavily you use the heat and how long you'll stay. Greater efficiency has more opportunity to repay its added cost during long, cold winters.

      Efficiency ratings describe energy conversion, not your bill; local fuel and electricity prices still matter.

      • Heavy heating use
        • Fuel savings accumulate over more hours
        • Higher upfront costs may pay back sooner
      • Light heating use
        • Smaller annual savings from efficiency upgrades
        • Installation costs weigh more heavily

      For fuel-burning furnaces, the highest efficiencies can require different venting and a condensation drain. Those installation costs belong in the savings calculation.

      Recall how you sleep with the heat running. If cycling noise or temperature swings bother you, heating controls deserve more of the budget.

      Multiple heating stages or an adjustable burner reduce heat output in milder weather; a variable-speed blower adjusts airflow.

        More adjustable operation can mean steadier warmth and quieter low-output runs, but it costs more and cannot compensate for poorly designed ducts.

        Top Furnaces
        Compare installed costs and estimated local energy bills before paying extra for a higher-efficiency model.
        Goodman GR9T961205DN Upflow/Horizontal Furnace
        Rating: 4.7 out of 5. 59 reviews
        Buy
        Why it stands out
        Upflow/horizontal installation suits homes needing two-stage gas heating in a compatible layout.
        Pros
        • Quiet operation
        • 96% AFUE rated heating efficiency
        • Two-stage heating accommodates different heating demands
        Trade-offs
        • Reported failures after two years and cracked pressure switches
        • Missing parts reported
        • Poor customer service reported
        Goodman GRVT800804CX
        Rating: 4.9 out of 5. 9 reviews
        Buy
        Why it stands out
        Two-stage heating suits homes needing an upflow or horizontal natural-gas furnace.
        Pros
        • Two-stage burner provides different heating output levels
        • Variable-speed blower allows airflow adjustment
        • Supports both upflow and horizontal installation
        Trade-offs
        • Requires metal flue venting
        • Propane use requires an LP conversion kit sold separately
        Rheem R962V0855A21M4SCAP Gas Furnace
        Buy
        Why it stands out
        Two-stage operation suits gas-heated homes with changing heating demands.
        Pros
        • Two-stage operation provides two heating levels
        • 96% AFUE indicates efficient fuel use for heating
        Trade-offs
        • Requires a gas supply; not an option for electricity-only heating
        Stelpro SFECM1821 Electric Furnace
        Buy
        Why it stands out
        Heat-pump compatibility suits electric heating systems that need variable-speed airflow.
        Pros
        • Variable-speed ECM motor allows airflow adjustment
        • Compatible with heat pump installations
        • Accessible components and replaceable element parts simplify servicing
        Trade-offs
        • Requires a compatible 240/208V electrical supply
        Coleman EBE15A 15kW Downflow Furnace
        Buy
        Why it stands out
        Downflow configuration suits older manufactured-home furnace replacements where the installation layout matches.
        Pros
        • High-efficiency ECM blower motor
        • Multi-speed blower provides airflow settings
        • Zero-clearance feature supports installation where space is limited
        Trade-offs
        • Thermostat sold separately
        • Downflow configuration must suit the home's duct layout
        • Requires freight-truck delivery
        Ouellet 21ECM15-A
        Buy
        Why it stands out
        15 kW electric heating suits installations with a compatible 240V, single-phase electrical supply.
        Pros
        • 10-year warranty
        Trade-offs
        • Requires a compatible 240V, single-phase electrical supply
        Allied Air 1.211101
        Buy
        Why it stands out
        Oil-heated homes needing a basement, front-flue furnace matched to an 87,000 BTU/h heating load.
        Pros
        • Variable-speed blower provides airflow control and quieter operation than single-speed motors
        • Airflow capacity up to 1,400 CFM supports larger residential duct systems
        Trade-offs
        • Basement, front-flue configuration limits installation options
        • Requires licensed HVAC installation and properly sized 6-inch flue venting
        • Requires an oil supply and 120 VAC power with a 15-amp fuse
        Style Crest Revolv Downflow Furnace With Coil Cabinet
        Buy
        Why it stands out
        Downflow, front-return oil heating suits manufactured or modular homes with a matching installation layout.
        Pros
        • Supports freestanding installation or placement in an alcove or closet
        • Includes a coil cabinet to accommodate an air-conditioning coil
        Trade-offs
        • Requires an oil fuel supply
        • Downflow airflow and front return must match the home's installation layout